Hull FC's 2025 Signings: A Report Card
It's that time again! We're diving deep into Hull FC's recruitment strategies, but this time, we're focusing on the players brought in under John Cartwright's leadership. How did the new faces fare? Let's find out!
For the upcoming 2026 season, Hull FC has once again made some significant signings, with Jake Arthur leading the charge. They've also welcomed experienced Super League players like Sam Lisone from Leeds Rhinos. But how did the previous year's recruits perform? Let's take a look at the grades.
Pre-2025 Recruitment
- Jordan Abdull – F: Unfortunately, Abdull's time with Hull FC was cut short before it even began. A knee injury sidelined him for the entire 2025 season, leading to his release. He's now looking to rebuild his career with Widnes Vikings. A tough start, indeed.
- John Asiata – B: Asiata's impact was undeniable when he was on the field. His presence significantly improved the team's performance. The grade hinges on his ability to stay fit.
- Amir Bourouh – C: Bourouh fulfilled his role, sharing time with Cade Cust as the primary hooker. A solid, reliable performance.
- Ed Chamberlain – D: Injuries plagued Chamberlain's season, and he's already been loaned out to Bradford Bulls for 2026. He often found himself playing in the pack due to circumstances.
- Cade Cust – B: Cust quickly proved his worth, earning a new contract. The versatile Australian excelled as a utility player, capable in the halves or at hooker, and will wear the number 14 shirt in 2026.
- Zak Hardaker – A: Arguably Hull FC's standout player in 2025, Hardaker played multiple positions to a high standard. With his contract expiring at the end of 2026, the club has a big decision to make.
- Oliver Holmes – E: Similar to Abdull, Holmes didn't play a competitive game due to injury and had to retire. The grade is slightly higher due to the team's need for players in the halves.
- Jordan Rapana – D: Rapana didn't quite deliver the impact Hull FC hoped for, and his early retirement suggests as much. However, he provided valuable experience to the young backs and even scored a try against rivals Hull KR.
- Hugo Salabio – D: Despite Hull FC's injury issues in the pack, Salabio didn't make a significant impact during his loan spell.
- Aidan Sezer – A: Sezer silenced any doubters with an impressive campaign, controlling the game and playing some of his best rugby in Super League.
2025 Mid-Season Recruitment
- Sam Eseh – C: Eseh made a positive impact during his loan spell, quickly becoming a fan favorite. However, he didn't sign permanently and returned to Wigan Warriors.
- Liam Knight – C: Knight was brought in to cover injuries in the pack. He started well but his performance tailed off, and he also faced some disciplinary issues. A full pre-season could make a difference in 2026.
- Will Pryce – C: Pryce showed flashes of brilliance, but injuries and an inconsistent spine hampered his progress. There's a lot of excitement for his future.
- Liam Watts – D: Watts played only eight times and has since left the club to join Championship side Goole Vikings.
Pre-2026 Recruitment
- Jake Arthur, Joe Batchelor, Connor Bailey, James Bell, Harvie Hill, Sam Lisone, Joe Phillips, Arthur Romano – B: The 2026 recruitment looks promising on paper. However, there are concerns about Joe Batchelor's injury history and James Bell's struggles in 2025. Young forwards Joe Phillips and Connor Bailey add depth, and Sam Lisone's signing bolsters the pack. Jake Arthur is the standout recruit.
What do you think? Did the grades align with your observations? Do you agree with the assessment of each player's impact? Share your thoughts in the comments below! And don't forget to check out the latest episode of The Serious About Rugby League Show on their YouTube channel for more insights!
